Sign up to stay up to date on the New Carlisle Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
305 Lightfoot Ct 3 2 1,635 $305,100 $186 4 days
58 Carlotta St 3 1 1,225 $192,500 $157 13 days
814 Bellows Dr 2 1 925 $169,900 $183 15 days
1005 White Pine St 3 1 975 $199,900 $205 26 days
803 Weinland St 3 1 999 $209,900 $210 28 days
127 S Main St N/A N/A 2,975 $175,000 $58 33 days
484 Winchester St 3 1 1,110 $199,900 $180 40 days
Dayton-Brandt Rd Unit Lot 4 N/A N/A N/A $314,500 Unknown 117 days
Dayton-Brandt Rd Unit Lot 1 N/A N/A N/A $295,000 Unknown 117 days
N Dayton-Lakeview Rd N/A N/A 222,156 $1,400,000 $6.30 463 days
Dayton-Brandt Rd Unit Lot 2 N/A N/A N/A $319,500 Unknown 117 days
11140 Milton Carlisle Rd N/A N/A 3,712 $899,900 $242 66 days
745 Hedwick St 3 1 999 $188,000 $188 110 days
N Dayton-Lakeview Rd N/A N/A N/A $225,000 Unknown 304 days
612 W Madison St 3 2 1,414 $200,000 $141 49 days
Dayton-Brandt Rd Unit Lot 3 N/A N/A N/A $314,500 Unknown 117 days
407 N Dayton Lakeview Rd 5 4 5,050 $859,900 $170 109 days
10833 Kendig Rd 4 3 2,212 $312,900 $141 82 days
111 N Church St 3 2 1,456 $250,000 $171 63 days
Average: 3.2 1.7 17,631 $370,073 $160 99 days
Viewing 1 - 19 of 19
Viewing 1 - 19 of 19
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
1257 Klose Ave 3 1 999 $190,000 $190 10 days
2774 N Dayton Lakeview Rd 4 3 1,787 $337,000 $188 25 days
939 Firwood Dr 4 1 1,050 $185,000 $176 26 days
7875 Staley Rd 5 5 3,856 $839,000 $217 27 days
307 Drake Ave 3 1 925 $149,900 $162 31 days
306 Funston Ave 3 2 1,198 $207,000 $172 32 days
1227 Styer Dr 3 1 999 $199,500 $199 40 days
5773 Short Rd 3 2 1,881 $399,900 $212 18 days
702 Fenview Dr 2 2 1,137 $199,000 $175 83 days
2656 Addison New Carlisle Rd 4 3 2,263 $675,000 $298 127 days
3479 Addison New Carlisle Rd 3 2 2,352 $725,000 $308 45 days
Average: 3.4 2.1 1,677 $373,300 $209 42 days
Viewing 1 - 11 of 11
Viewing 1 - 11 of 11
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
501 S Main St 3 2 1,238 $219,000 $224,000 $180 31 days 7/24/26
1424 N Lake Rd 3 3 2,711 $650,000 $585,000 $215 46 days 7/24/26
805 Brookfield Dr 3 1 864 $204,900 $205,000 $237 31 days 7/20/26
9475 W National Rd 3 1 1,014 $189,900 $195,000 $192 79 days 7/20/26
825 Free Rd 4 2 2,057 $449,000 $449,000 $218 30 days 7/14/26
1729 Hocker Ave 4 2 1,984 $259,800 $259,800 $130 200 days 7/14/26
8020 E New Carlisle Rd 6 2 2,803 $510,000 $470,000 $167 156 days 7/14/26
613 Weinland St 2 1 999 $184,900 $185,000 $185 40 days 7/9/26
815 Plumwood Dr 3 1 1,200 $215,000 $209,000 $174 30 days 7/2/26
906 W Lake Ave 6 4 2,000 $310,000 $310,000 $155 75 days 7/1/26
558 Bowser St 3 2 1,449 $236,900 $239,900 $165 55 days 6/30/26
723 Colony Trl 4 4 2,772 $435,000 $435,000 $156 59 days 6/30/26
607 W Lake Ave 2 1 820 $179,000 $183,000 $223 38 days 6/29/26
489 Caldwell Cir 3 2 1,365 $249,900 $249,900 $183 90 days 6/29/26
810 Bayberry Dr 3 1 1,135 $209,900 $209,900 $184 43 days 6/26/26
828 Hedwick St 4 2 1,424 $235,000 $199,000 $139 33 days 6/25/26
332 Galewood Dr 3 2 1,200 $210,000 $210,000 $175 68 days 6/24/26
307 Garfield St 4 2 1,856 $239,900 $210,000 $113 31 days 6/22/26
415 Falcon Dr 4 2 1,316 $235,000 $237,000 $180 45 days 6/22/26
1146 Klose Ave 3 1 999 $179,900 $185,000 $185 35 days 6/19/26
752 Hedwick St 3 1 999 $184,900 $178,000 $178 73 days 6/8/26
1589 Bending Tree Dr 4 3 2,250 $439,900 $439,900 $195 23 days 5/29/26
202 Braun St 3 2 1,429 $230,000 $235,000 $164 42 days 5/28/26
6429 Winding Tree Dr 5 3 2,718 $519,900 $527,000 $193 19 days 5/27/26
5490 S Dayton Brandt Rd 3 2 1,716 $399,900 $399,900 $233 32 days 5/19/26
2126 Liberty Rd 3 3 2,243 $359,900 $345,000 $153 38 days 5/15/26
1008 Stevens Circle Dr 3 3 2,178 $299,900 $299,900 $137 36 days 5/13/26
303 Villa Dr 3 1 1,432 $199,900 $200,000 $139 33 days 5/12/26
208 Rawson Dr 3 1 864 $159,900 $161,900 $187 102 days 5/5/26
469 Bischoff Rd 2 2 2,038 $289,900 $331,500 $162 27 days 5/5/26
1300 Edgebrook Ave 3 2 1,380 $234,900 $234,900 $170 35 days 5/1/26
608 W Washington St 3 2 1,682 $258,000 $244,000 $145 41 days 5/1/26
801 Brubaker Dr 4 3 1,510 $286,900 $285,000 $188 65 days 4/27/26
304 W Madison St 3 2 1,656 $249,900 $255,000 $153 25 days 4/20/26
3535 Ruby Dr 3 2 1,144 $265,000 $255,000 $222 37 days 4/17/26
14-16 Ditmer Dr 12 8 5,698 $990,000 $900,000 $157 64 days 3/27/26
1122 Chalet Ave 3 1 1,225 $112,000 $116,000 $94 40 days 3/25/26
227 Rawson Dr 3 1 864 $174,900 $167,900 $194 42 days 3/19/26
1650 Cranbrook Dr 3 4 3,466 $469,500 $455,000 $131 67 days 3/16/26
5344 S Dayton Brandt Rd 3 1 1,730 $359,900 $330,000 $190 125 days 3/13/26
210 Zimmerman St 3 1 1,053 $189,000 $186,000 $176 34 days 3/4/26
1001 Langdale Ave 3 2 1,336 $149,900 $145,000 $108 49 days 2/27/26
303 N Smith St 3 2 1,605 $260,000 $255,000 $158 48 days 2/26/26
6771 W National Rd 5 2 1,449 $275,000 $272,000 $187 36 days 2/25/26
315 N Main St 4 1 1,263 $190,000 $195,000 $154 59 days 1/30/26
11501 Zeller Dr 4 3 3,872 $475,000 $470,000 $121 59 days 1/30/26
Average: 3.6 2.1 1,739 $296,239 $289,878 $171 53 days
Viewing 1 - 46 of 46
Viewing 1 - 46 of 46