Sign up to stay up to date on the New Carlisle Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
336 Prentice Drive 3 1 925 $139,900 $151 6 days
1035 Bischoff Road 3 2 1,568 $440,000 $280 10 days
7788 Staley Road 4 2 1,820 $309,900 $170 12 days
1651 Lundgren Road 3 1 1,225 $159,900 $130 13 days
11219 Ayres 3 2 2,142 $567,500 $264 17 days
8246 Detrick Jordan Pike 3 2 1,636 $274,900 $168 21 days
1824 Styer Drive N/A N/A 1,884 $369,900 $196 20 days
516 N Church Street 4 2 1,892 $185,000 $97 61 days
8021 Troy Rd 4 1 2,488 $148,900 $59 63 days
107 W Washington Street N/A N/A 3,542 $199,900 $56 67 days
4566 New Carlisle Saint Paris Road 3 3 1,920 $599,900 $312 137 days
4566 New Carlisle Saint Paris Road 3 3 1,920 $599,900 $312 138 days
Average: 3.3 1.9 1,913 $332,966 $183 47 days
Viewing 1 - 12 of 12
Viewing 1 - 12 of 12
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
1101 Cambridge Court 4 2 2,019 $179,900 $89 4 days
502 Zimmerman Street 2 2 1,158 $157,000 $135 14 days
513 N Church Street 3 1 891 $120,000 $134 24 days
504 Funston Avenue 4 2 1,600 $185,000 $115 2 days
6785 W National Road 3 1 1,488 $184,900 $124 26 days
1003 White Pine Street 4 1 1,250 $149,900 $119 22 days
357 Winchester Street 3 1 875 $131,700 $150 22 days
5631 S Scarff Road 3 3 1,823 $389,900 $213 18 days
136 Milton Carlisle Road 3 2 1,808 $238,000 $131 29 days
12330 Stafford Road 3 2 2,248 $375,000 $166 45 days
1103 Grissom Avenue 3 1 1,181 $149,900 $126 37 days
3517 Ruby Drive 3 2 1,144 $175,000 $152 27 days
1392 N Hampton Road 4 3 2,203 $525,000 $238 41 days
203 N Smith Street 4 3 1,934 $259,900 $134 34 days
2827 Country Squire Drive 2 2 1,933 $259,900 $134 45 days
301 N Medway Carlisle Road 3 3 2,550 $375,000 $147 69 days
1308 Fyffe Avenue 3 1 1,323 $184,900 $139 11 days
6225 Scarff Road 3 2 1,248 $275,000 $220 4 days
7800 Detrick Jordan Pike 4 3 3,483 $569,900 $163 50 days
2621 Sugar Tree Trail 3 3 2,478 $347,900 $140 55 days
409 W Jefferson 4 3 2,647 $119,900 $45 84 days
601 W Madision Street 4 3 1,855 $214,900 $115 58 days
1227 Frayne Drive 3 1 1,073 $162,900 $151 3 days
9900 Bellefontaine Road 3 3 2,594 $375,000 $144 3 days
Average: 3.2 2.1 1,783 $254,433 $143 29 days
Viewing 1 - 24 of 24
Viewing 1 - 24 of 24
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
303 Zimmerman Street 3 2 1,125 $169,900 $175,000 $155 2 days 9/22/22
201 Braun Street 4 2 1,191 $179,900 $165,000 $138 64 days 9/22/22
1732 Styer Drive 3 1 962 $154,900 $154,900 $161 70 days 9/20/22
302 W Washington Street 4 2 1,958 $199,900 $199,900 $102 2 days 9/16/22
227 Rawson Drive 3 1 864 $139,900 $139,900 $161 2 days 9/13/22
410 Kennison Avenue 4 2 1,688 $200,000 $205,000 $121 2 days 9/2/22
850 Whaley Road 3 3 3,282 $549,900 $549,900 $167 19 days 9/1/22
7625 Ballentine 3 1 1,820 $220,000 $200,000 $109 30 days 9/1/22
7991 W National Road 4 3 2,836 $389,900 $399,500 $140 69 days 9/1/22
7650 W National Road 2 1 946 $195,000 $195,000 $206 5 days 8/31/22
1107 Chalet Drive 3 1 1,323 $135,900 $135,000 $102 24 days 8/31/22
1009 Cliffside Drive 3 1 925 $129,900 $135,000 $145 4 days 8/30/22
301 Villa Drive 3 2 1,474 $190,000 $190,000 $128 1 day 8/26/22
11817 Cowpath Road 4 2 1,795 $240,000 $220,500 $122 14 days 8/19/22
2822 Country Squire Drive 4 3 2,748 $425,000 $408,000 $148 21 days 8/16/22
1132 Fyffe Avenue 3 1 999 $149,900 $139,000 $139 52 days 8/9/22
158 Winchester Street 3 1 875 $150,000 $150,000 $171 8 days 8/8/22
1754 Styer Drive 4 1 1,438 $150,000 $145,000 $100 28 days 8/8/22
1117 Chalet Avenue 3 1 999 $145,000 $145,000 $145 1 day 8/1/22
326 Fenwick Drive 3 1 864 $140,000 $140,000 $162 2 days 7/29/22
1225 Bookwalter Avenue 3 2 1,474 $197,500 $197,500 $133 11 days 7/29/22
302 Jefferson Street 4 2 2,037 $179,900 $174,000 $85 67 days 7/29/22
5781 Scarff Road 4 3 4,776 $520,000 $530,000 $110 38 days 7/25/22
522 N Scott Street 3 1 1,024 $112,000 $112,000 $109 24 days 7/25/22
1615 Lammes Lane 3 2 1,624 $215,000 $222,222 $136 4 days 7/22/22
13535 Cowpath Road 4 1 2,490 $329,000 $329,000 $132 1 day 7/22/22
1631 Bending Tree Drive 4 3 2,154 $279,900 $285,500 $132 12 days 7/22/22
717 Spinning Road 3 1 875 $139,900 $135,000 $154 22 days 7/18/22
4574 Addison New Carlisle Road 3 2 1,592 $199,900 $199,000 $125 2 days 7/8/22
603 W Lake Avenue 4 2 1,775 $199,900 $207,600 $116 2 days 7/8/22
548 Bischoff Road 3 3 2,074 $595,000 $621,000 $299 2 days 7/8/22
1146 Klose Avenue 3 1 999 $139,900 $150,700 $150 0 days 6/30/22
788 Free Road 3 2 1,436 $265,000 $245,000 $170 63 days 6/30/22
608 Walsh Drive 4 2 999 $189,900 $201,000 $201 2 days 6/21/22
1206 Bookwalter Avenue 4 2 1,311 $199,900 $188,000 $143 3 days 6/21/22
5210 N Dayton Lakeview Road 3 2 1,856 $299,999 $299,000 $161 2 days 6/17/22
1005 White Pine Street 3 1 975 $145,000 $160,000 $164 4 days 6/17/22
221 Prentice Drive 3 1 925 $129,000 $134,000 $144 4 days 6/13/22
1101 Edgebrook Avenue 4 2 1,304 $178,000 $178,000 $136 1 day 6/3/22
100 Hillcrest Avenue 3 2 1,404 $149,000 $137,000 $97 4 days 6/1/22
305 N Henry Street 3 2 1,282 $189,900 $190,000 $148 2 days 5/25/22
809 Bayberry Drive 3 2 1,379 $154,900 $149,000 $108 3 days 5/25/22
S Dayton Lakeview Road N/A N/A 5 $219,900 $180,000 Unknown 48 days 5/25/22
408 Zimmerman Street 3 2 1,053 $147,500 $165,000 $156 6 days 5/25/22
1259 Bookwalter Avenue 4 2 1,608 $205,000 $205,000 $127 3 days 5/13/22
106 Galewood Drive 3 1 925 $139,000 $139,000 $150 40 days 5/13/22
523 Hamilton Avenue 3 2 1,004 $169,900 $175,000 $174 1 day 5/4/22
705 Jefferson Street 3 2 1,920 $162,900 $157,000 $81 18 days 4/28/22
8101 W National Road 3 3 1,804 $399,900 $399,900 $221 25 days 4/26/22
135 Orth Drive 5 4 2,900 $199,000 $207,500 $71 1 day 4/22/22
Average: 3.3 1.8 1,522 $213,896 $212,936 $793 16 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 55
Viewing 1 - 50 of 55