Sign up to stay up to date on the New Carlisle Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
812 Applewood Drive 3 1 875 $125,000 $142 12 days
1026 Frayne Drive 3 1 1,505 $169,900 $112 20 days
408 N Main Street N/A N/A 3,654 $250,000 $68 145 days
8917 S Palmer Road 4 3 3,463 $1,475,000 $425 101 days
8917 S Palmer Road 4 3 3,463 $1,475,000 $425 100 days
8246 Detrick Jordan Pike 3 2 1,636 $260,000 $158 155 days
1824 Styer Drive N/A N/A 1,884 $369,900 $196 154 days
Average: 3.4 2.0 2,354 $589,257 $218 98 days
Viewing 1 - 7 of 7
Viewing 1 - 7 of 7
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
423 N Church Street 3 1 1,016 $115,000 $113 1 day
3195 Addison-New Carlisle Road 3 2 2,304 $344,900 $149 1 day
11810 Stafford Road 4 3 1,942 $429,900 $221 35 days
612 Willowick Drive 3 1 975 $159,900 $164 20 days
314 Drake Avenue 3 1 925 $127,500 $137 64 days
231 N Dayton Lakeview Road 3 2 1,224 $239,900 $195 55 days
9025 Bellefontaine Road N/A N/A 4,608 $249,900 $54 82 days
520 N Church Street 3 1 1,060 $138,000 $130 110 days
211 N Smith Street 3 3 1,610 $230,000 $142 82 days
607 Colony Trail 3 2 1,621 $299,800 $184 98 days
336 Prentice Drive 3 1 925 $117,400 $126 132 days
7788 Staley Road 4 2 3,640 $294,900 $81 146 days
9900 Bellefontaine Road 3 3 2,594 $375,000 $144 3 days
Average: 3.2 1.8 1,880 $240,161 $142 53 days
Viewing 1 - 13 of 13
Viewing 1 - 13 of 13
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
1106 Langdale Avenue 3 2 960 $154,900 $154,900 $161 23 days 2/2/23
878 Portland Avenue 4 2 1,175 $179,400 $168,000 $142 31 days 2/1/23
504 Colony Trail 4 3 2,072 $289,900 $282,100 $136 53 days 2/1/23
1250 Frayne Drive 4 2 1,325 $179,900 $185,000 $139 2 days 1/25/23
308 S Adams Street 3 3 1,345 $165,000 $150,000 $111 2 days 1/13/23
960 Narcissus Drive 3 1 925 $154,900 $154,900 $167 11 days 1/13/23
419 E Carpenter Drive 3 1 1,107 $129,500 $132,000 $119 37 days 1/13/23
613 Colony Trail 3 2 1,670 $290,000 $290,000 $173 82 days 1/13/23
213 Drake Avenue 3 1 864 $129,900 $130,500 $151 38 days 1/12/23
440 Whaley Road 3 3 2,140 $339,900 $320,000 $149 51 days 1/5/23
37 Weinland Street 3 1 1,107 $149,000 $152,500 $137 49 days 1/4/23
303 Funston Avenue 3 1 950 $149,900 $145,000 $152 19 days 12/28/22
1006 Campbell Avenue 3 1 1,045 $159,900 $165,000 $157 3 days 12/16/22
11293 Carriage Hill Drive 4 3 1,954 $297,500 $291,000 $148 7 days 12/16/22
11676 Marquart Road 3 2 1,456 $325,000 $315,000 $216 35 days 12/9/22
11219 Ayres 3 2 2,142 $499,900 $350,000 $163 57 days 12/7/22
2665 Liberty 3 3 2,160 $449,900 $400,000 $185 8 days 12/5/22
100 S Main Street N/A N/A 3,600 $225,000 $200,000 $55 19 days 11/30/22
101 S Clay Street 2 1 1,290 $155,000 $145,000 $112 19 days 11/30/22
874 Narcissus Drive 3 1 925 $135,000 $137,000 $148 11 days 11/23/22
321 Stratmore Street 3 1 1,073 $165,000 $165,000 $153 5 days 11/21/22
1778 N Hampton Road 3 2 1,361 $399,999 $385,000 $282 25 days 11/16/22
304 W Madison Street 3 2 1,656 $199,900 $195,000 $117 7 days 11/15/22
4566 New Carlisle Saint Paris Road 3 3 1,920 $599,900 $599,900 $312 175 days 11/8/22
1035 Bischoff Road 3 2 1,568 $429,000 $412,000 $262 18 days 11/2/22
136 Milton Carlisle Road 3 2 1,808 $238,000 $238,000 $131 29 days 11/1/22
212 N Smith Street 3 3 1,632 $246,900 $240,000 $147 13 days 10/31/22
6785 W National Road 3 1 1,488 $184,900 $182,000 $122 26 days 10/31/22
12330 Stafford Road 3 2 2,248 $375,000 $363,750 $161 45 days 10/20/22
1101 Cambridge Court 4 2 2,019 $179,900 $175,000 $86 4 days 10/18/22
3517 Ruby Drive 3 2 1,144 $175,000 $185,000 $161 27 days 10/18/22
502 Zimmerman Street 2 2 1,158 $157,000 $157,000 $135 5 days 10/17/22
1103 Grissom Avenue 3 1 1,181 $149,900 $149,900 $126 37 days 10/14/22
203 N Smith Street 4 3 1,934 $259,900 $255,000 $131 34 days 10/14/22
2827 Country Squire Drive 2 2 1,933 $259,900 $244,700 $126 45 days 10/13/22
1003 White Pine Street 4 1 1,250 $149,900 $151,900 $121 22 days 10/12/22
513 N Church Street 3 1 891 $120,000 $125,000 $140 6 days 10/11/22
504 Funston Avenue 4 2 1,600 $185,000 $188,000 $117 2 days 10/5/22
301 N Medway Carlisle Road 3 3 2,550 $375,000 $352,500 $138 76 days 10/4/22
357 Winchester Street 3 1 875 $131,700 $131,700 $150 22 days 10/3/22
1392 N Hampton Road 4 3 2,203 $525,000 $555,000 $251 41 days 10/3/22
5631 S Scarff Road 3 3 1,823 $389,900 $400,500 $219 18 days 9/30/22
409 W Jefferson 4 3 2,647 $119,900 $110,000 $41 84 days 9/29/22
2621 Sugar Tree Trail 3 3 2,478 $347,900 $335,000 $135 55 days 9/27/22
7800 Detrick Jordan Pike 4 3 3,483 $569,900 $560,000 $160 50 days 9/26/22
303 Zimmerman Street 3 2 1,125 $169,900 $175,000 $155 2 days 9/22/22
201 Braun Street 4 2 1,191 $179,900 $165,000 $138 64 days 9/22/22
1732 Styer Drive 3 1 962 $154,900 $154,900 $161 70 days 9/20/22
302 W Washington Street 4 2 1,958 $199,900 $199,900 $102 2 days 9/16/22
227 Rawson Drive 3 1 864 $139,900 $139,900 $161 2 days 9/13/22
Average: 3.2 1.9 1,624 $244,055 $237,405 $148 29 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 65
Viewing 1 - 50 of 65