Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$467,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048362 MLS
Unique Indian Lake property with character, charm, and shared waterfront access! Located on beautiful Seminole Island, this one-of-a-kind home is surrounded by mature woods and sits just across the street from a private waterfront beach area. Thoughtfully customized with tons of character, the home features 2 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and new flooring throughout. The location and layout make this home a great vacation rental opportunity! The inviting main level offers an open feel and a bedroom with convenient built-in storage. A beautiful open staircase leads to the spacious second-floor primary bedroom, complete with an en-suite bath. Both bathrooms have been recently updated with new fixtures and finishes. The kitchen is truly the heart of this home, featuring updated stainless steel appliances added in 2025, shiplap walls, a beverage refrigerator, and a new sink and faucets. Just beyond the kitchen, the laundry room provides access to the backyard, where you'll find a fully fenced yard and a large paver patio perfect for entertaining. And then there's ''The Cabin'' -- a 24' x 24' detached bonus space offering endless possibilities for overnight guests, a gathering space, an office , game room, or additional living area. Previous owners utilized the Cabin as extra sleeping space for vacation rentals. Outdoor amenities continue with two storage sheds and a carport. Also included with the property is a 1/9th ownership interest in the waterfront lot, offering a private beach area, fire pit, and green space -- the perfect place to relax by the water, enjoy a sunset, or spend time with family and friends. If you're looking for something truly different at Indian Lake or a rental/investment opportunity, this special Seminole Island property offers a unique combination of privacy, character, outdoor living, and waterfront access.

10731 Piqua Dr, Huntsville
$499,900
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1048151 MLS
Tucked away on just over 5 acres, this spacious 2023 built home offers the privacy and breathing room you've been looking for, while still keeping everyday conveniences close by. With 2,877 square feet of living space, 5 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, a full basement, and attached 2-car garage, there's plenty of room both inside and out. Inside, the open-concept living, dining, and kitchen areas create an inviting space for everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen features beautiful cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, tile backsplash, recessed lighting, and a large center island with additional seating. The adjoining living area offers plenty of natural light and an electric fireplace, with sliding doors leading to the backyard. The main-level primary suite features a spacious bedroom, private bath with dual-sink vanity and large tiled walk-in shower, along with an impressive walk-in closet. Two additional bedrooms offer flexibility, with one currently being used as a recreation/game room. A dedicated laundry room adds even more convenience, and space. The full basement provides an incredible amount of additional space for storage, hobbies, a home gym, workshop, or future finished living area. Outside is where this property really stands apart. Spread across 5.05 acres and tucked back from the road, this home offers a sense of privacy with plenty of yard and mature trees surrounding the home, and just across the street, you'll find a park, adding another great outdoor amenity right outside your door. Convenient access to US 33, State Route 117, and State Route 274. keeps Indian Lake, Bellefontaine, Marysville. Columbus and surrounding communities within easy reach, giving you that tucked-away feeling without being far from everything. Newer construction, over 2,800 square feet, 5+ acres, and a private setting; this is one you'll want to see in person. Schedule your private showing today!

3837 Township Road 221, Huntsville
$939,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1047659 MLS
Experience the best of lake living in this beautifully renovated 3 bed, 2 bath waterfront ranch on Tecumseh Island at Indian Lake. Thoughtfully redesigned from top to bottom, this move-in-ready home blends modern luxury with effortless waterfront entertaining. The open, inviting interior features luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, fresh paint and trim, solid wood interior doors, quartz kitchen countertops, new stainless appliances, an electric built-in fireplace, updated lighting & ceiling fans, and completely remodeled bathrooms . The custom bar room is an entertainer's dream, showcasing Amish-built cabinetry, a full-size refrigerator, a 2024 Hoshizaki ice maker, water filtration, French doors to the living room & its own Mitsubishi mini-split system. Additional upgrades include a tankless water heater, whole-home water softener and pressure tank, new well pump, updated attic plumbing, Bluetooth bathroom exhaust fans, and a custom Container Store closet system. Outside, every detail has been carefully considered. Completed in 2022, the exterior improvements include new siding, windows, enclosed garage with new doors and openers, gutter guards, professionally installed sod, extensive tree removal, and all-new concrete including the driveway, patios & sidewalks. Underground drainage has been installed from the driveway and gutters directly to the lake for added functionality. Enjoy evenings around the custom gas fire pit by Concrete Wave Design or host gatherings with the Phantom motorized garage screen that transforms the bonus room into the perfect party space. The backyard is complete with an TurboTwister waterslide for endless summer fun. You will love the fully updated boathouse featuring a new roof, siding, gutters, soffits, and a new boat lift with motor, cables, switch, and cradle. Whether you're looking for a full-time or the perfect waterfront getaway, you won't want to miss this opportu

9024 Walnut St, Huntsville
$400,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1047719 MLS
Set on 3.309 acres in McArthur Township, this spacious 4-bedroom, 3-full-bath home offers 3,088 square feet of living space in the Indian Lake School District. Built by Mike Brunner, the home features an open living and dining area with exposed beams, a kitchen with black cabinetry, newer dishwasher and refrigerator, and a primary bedroom with private deck, walk-in closet, and additional linen storage. A lower-level studio with a bathroom and stand-up shower provides additional flexibility and may provide the potential for a 5th bedroom. The home includes two furnaces, two central air units, two water heaters, a water softener, well pump (approximately two years old), 200-amp electrical service, and a laundry room with mop sink. Some windows have been replaced. Outside, the fenced yard includes a pool, tree house with sandbox, utility shed with concrete floor, and approximately one acre of hay field. The property also features a private well and septic system, buried propane tank, attached 2-car garage, patio, and covered porch. A rural setting with room to enjoy the outdoors, yet conveniently located near Indian Lake, Huntsville, and Bellefontaine. Call today for your appointment to see this home!

3971 W State Route 274, Huntsville
$339,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1047500 MLS
MAJOR PRICE IMPROVEMENT! NOW $339,900! Sellers are motivated and have aggressively repositioned this property to get it SOLD! Rarely does a home on highly desirable Seminole Island undergo a transformation this extensive. Completely reimagined from the ground up, this exceptional Indian Lake home blends modern luxury with timeless character in one of the lake's most sought after communities. The thoughtfully redesigned floor plan is anchored by a dramatic floor to ceiling stone fireplace, while natural limestone accent walls add warmth and character. The open concept design flows seamlessly into the all new kitchen featuring a large center island, quality cabinetry, modern finishes and the perfect space for entertaining family and friends. The redesigned layout offers a true primary suite with an oversized walk in closet leading directly into a beautifully renovated spa inspired bath featuring a custom tiled walk in shower with glass enclosure and designer finishes. A spiral staircase leads to the third bedroom and loft, providing flexible space for guests, a home office or additional sleeping accommodations. Extensive updates include a new roof, siding, plumbing, updated electrical, sewer line, gas line, HVAC, kitchen, bathroom, flooring, walls, interior and exterior doors, several new windows, gutters, fascia, fresh paint and new deck boards. Outside, enjoy the spacious deck and oversized detached two car garage with dedicated workshop space and plenty of room for vehicles, boats, golf carts, jet skis and all your lake toys. Located on coveted Seminole Island, you're moments from boating, fishing, waterfront restaurants, marinas and everything Indian Lake has to offer. Ideal as a year round residence or weekend getaway! Call an agent to schedule your showing today!

9885 Blackhawk Dr, Huntsville
$625,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1047553 MLS
Location, location, location!! This stick-built ranch home is situated on a HUGE lot on Dunn's Pond at Indian. The double covered boat dock sets off to the side as not to obstruct one's views. The water is calm here and is perfect for swimming and kayaking. Outside features also include an amazing, covered deck w/gazebo, two sheds, an awesome firepit and plenty of yard for friends and family to play games. Inside features include an enormous, eat-in kitchen w/granite countertops, separate dining area, bar area at island, and more. There are three bedrooms, a fourth room used for quilting and one full bath. Don't miss the huge bonus room that is currently used for quilting machine but could easily be an additional bedroom, huge dining room for those special family dinners, work-out room and more! GENERAC GENERATOR IS INCLUDED IN THE SALE! This one is a 'must see!!

7711 Edgewater Ave, Huntsville
$975,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1047173 MLS
Beautiful waterfront home located on Lakeridge Island at Indian Lake! This impressive property offers 253 feet of shoreline, panoramic open-water views, and the calm waters of a no-wake zone, making docking effortless. Designed for entertaining, the outdoor spaces are perfect for lake living. Enjoy a double covered dock with a steel frame and electric lifts, an outdoor shower, waterside fire ring, and parking for up to 12 vehicles. Whether you're hosting family and friends or looking for an excellent short-term rental opportunity, this property checks every box. Inside, enjoy 3382 sq ft of living space with plenty of windows to admire the gorgeous water views. With 6 bedrooms and 4 full bathrooms, there's room for everyone. The main level features 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. Upstairs you'll find an additional 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths, including an owner's suite with en suite bath. The updated kitchen features leathered granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and flows into a dining area where the included table comfortably seats up to 16 guests. New luxury vinyl plank flooring spans the main level, and all appliances stay. Two separate living rooms provide space to gather and unwind--one featuring a wood-burning fireplace and the other a cozy gas fireplace. A two-car attached garage, new roof (October 2025), and concrete and steel seawall installed in 2018 add lasting value and peace of mind. Whether you're searching for a year-round residence, the ultimate weekend getaway, or an investment property, this is more than a home--it's where unforgettable memories are made and every day feels like vacation at Indian Lake.

9039 Buckeye Dr, Huntsville
$929,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1047172 MLS
Lake life is calling! Gorgeous 4 bed/2 bath custom waterfront home built by Crale in 2022. Enjoy open-water views from both sides of the house. Nestled on desirable Lakeridge Island in a protected no-wake zone, it's the perfect place for swimming, paddleboarding, and kayaking. The covered dock with an electric lift makes getting out on the water a breeze, while the spacious composite deck built over the lake is the perfect spot to relax, entertain, or catch the beautiful sunrise. With 2,350 square feet, this FULLY FURNISHED home is truly move-in ready! The bright main floor living room features vaulted ceilings and a stunning wall of windows overlooking the water, filling the home with natural light. The stylish kitchen features white cabinetry, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and custom built barnwood dining table that's ready for everything from pancake breakfasts to game nights. The main floor offers one bedroom and one full bath, while the loft provides an additional private bedroom. Downstairs, you'll find two more bedrooms, full bath, a bar with leathered granite counter, and a second living room with a walkout to the covered patio. The waterside storage room keeps your fishing gear, lake toys, and lawn equipment organized. The driveway has enough room to park 6 cars! Whether it's boating with friends, floating all afternoon, roasting marshmallows after sunset, or making memories with family that last a lifetime, this is the kind of place where everyone will want to gather year after year.

8914 State Route 368, Huntsville
$249,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1046747 MLS
This extremely nice, 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch home is situated on 3 lots (includes parcels #510330510012000,3000) and is very close to Silver Dollar Pond, Dunn's Pond, and minutes to rental docks at Moundwood State Park. The large, open livingroom/dining room features a gas fireplace and sliding doors exiting to patio area. The kitchen has plenty of cabinets and counter space. Closets have shelving. Property has 3 sheds! Recent updates include new flooring in kitchen, living room & dining room in 2026. New roof on patio in 2024, and new roof on the house in 2020. Must see to appreciate. Immaculate inside and out.

7691 Pontiac St, Huntsville
$259,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1044525 MLS
Nestled on the serene Shawnee Island, this adorable 2-bedroom, 1 bath lake cottage is a dream retreat!The extra large living area offers potential for a third bedroom, making it perfect for guests or a growing family. Step outside to enjoy the covered gazebo and fenced in pet area, ideal for outdoor relaxation and entertaining. The updated kitchen and bath provide modern comfort and style. With worry-free maintenance thanks to all new exterior doors, windows, roof, siding, and water pressure tank you can spend more time enjoying lake life! Located in a golf cart community, you're just a stone's throw away from Cranberry Resort and Pew Island state park. Furnishings negotiable, and possession at closing. Don't miss this opportunity to own a piece of the island!

9484 Buckeye Dr, Huntsville
$279,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1046047 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath single-family home that perfectly blends comfort and style while enjoying serene water views from your windows. Step inside to discover modern flooring throughout and a freshly updated kitchen that's ready for all of your needs. Downstairs, the finished basement features a bar and walk-out access to the backyard—ideal for hosting unforgettable summer gatherings. Whether you're relaxing with friends or enjoying a quiet evening by the water, this home offers the lifestyle you've been looking for.

3687 Bell Rd, Huntsville
$269,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1046425 MLS
This three bedroom, one bath home is situated on 1.3 acre lot in the Village of Huntsville. It has a full, unfinished basement. The home has been freshly painted and has many updates. There is a nice breezeway between the home and the attached, oversized garage. There is a nice porch on the front of the home and a huge patio in the rear. The living room/kitchen area are very open and the kitchen has been updated with new flooring, amazing appliances, beautiful cabinets and countertop and more! Laundry area is off of the kitcen. There is a large outbuilding/shed for your tools and mower. There is C/A and propane heat.

7038 State Route 117, Huntsville
$598,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1045530 MLS
Welcome to Blue Heron Cove! This prestigious, tree-lined street leads you home to this charming waterfront escape. With it's soaring rooflines and unique floor plan, this home offers character, space and fantastic views of the cove leading out to the open waters. You can just imagine the lake breeze drifting through the expansive living area that is highlighted by cathedral ceilings and natural light. Step outside to the oversized waterfront deck along the 66 ft of water-frontage that is perfect for morning coffee, sunset gatherings, or simply soaking in the peaceful sounds. A winding brick walkway leads you down to the boat house, inviting endless days of boating, fishing, and lakeside memories. The spacious bedrooms provide roomful everyone to unwind, while the private balcony off of the primary suite creates a perfect retreat to start your day or end your day overlooking the water. Let's talk about the storage here! The primary walk-in closet seems endless and there is ample cabinet space throughout. The garage is heated with its own furnace and offers plenty of space for storage or workshop usage. Whether entertaining a crowd or enjoying a quiet weekend escape, this home delivers the relaxed waterfront lifestyle with space, comfort and a vacation feel everyday.

8095 Blue Heron Cv, Huntsville
$249,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1046192 MLS
Don't miss this fantastic opportunity to own a home located very close to the lake, with convenient state-rental docks nearby for easy water access. The main level features a spacious, open-concept layout that brings the kitchen, living room, and dining area together in one bright, inviting space--perfect for gatherings, weekend retreats, or full-time living. This level also includes one bedroom and a full bath, offering comfortable single-floor living when needed. Upstairs, the second level provides two additional bedrooms and another full bath, giving everyone room to spread out. The home has been freshly painted, creating a clean, move-in-ready feel, and the new overhead garage door adds both curb appeal and convenience. Whether you're looking for a year-round residence, a lake getaway, or an investment opportunity, this property delivers location, space, and value.

9010 State Route 368, Huntsville