Between $200,000 - $300,000 New Carlisle OH Real Estate, Homes, Condos for Sale

More pictures will be available soon. Welcome home to this spacious 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath residence nestled in a family-friendly neighborhood with all the charm and warmth of small-town living. Featuring an open floor plan, this move-in ready home offers comfortable living spaces perfect for everyday life and entertaining. Step outside to enjoy the fenced backyard, perfect for children, pets, and outdoor gatherings. The detached two-car garage offers ample space for parking, storage, or a workshop area. Enjoy the convenience of being just a short drive from Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, while also benefiting from a peaceful community setting. Located near a neighborhood park and local school, this home provides easy access to outdoor recreation and everyday amenities. Whether you're looking for room to grow or a welcoming place to call home, this property combines comfort, convenience, and small-town appeal in one desirable package.

903 Pepperwood Dr, New Carlisle

$265,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1049240 MLS

Bring your vision to life with this farmhouse full of character, charm, and opportunity! This 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home in the country sits on 1.5 acres and is surrounded by mature trees and rolling hills. Enjoy the sunrises on the covered side patio and rear deck or relax with evening sunsets on the enclosed front porch. The primary bedroom and two full baths are conveniently located on the first floor. The basement offers a large 18'x26' finished rec room. The fully fenced back yard connects to the detached 2 car plus garage with a workshop that is insulated and heated and could be ideal for contractors or hobbyist.. Located in the back of the property is a 60'x40' barn with a lean-to on both ends that each measure at 17'x40'. You can explore the opportunities of owning small livestock or just enjoy the extra storage space. You could also use the barn for camper or boat storage earning extra income or use it as a business workshop. Whether you're dreaming of a cozy country retreat, a family home with character, or your next investment project, this property is full of possibilities. Don't miss your opportunity, call today to schedule your showing.

5675 Day Brandt Rd, New Carlisle

$242,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1049216 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully updated home in New Carlisle, Ohio! Featuring 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, this home offers a fresh, modern feel with numerous improvements throughout. Step inside to discover fresh paint, new flooring, and brand-new interior doors that create a clean and inviting atmosphere. The updated kitchen boasts new cabinets, granite countertops, and new appliances, making it a wonderful space for cooking and entertaining. Enjoy added peace of mind with extensive updates, including a completely rewired home, new water heater, new furnace and A/C, and a new roof and gutters. The exterior has also been freshly painted, giving the home great curb appeal. Outside, you'll find a fenced-in backyard and a newly poured concrete patio, perfect for relaxing, entertaining guests, or enjoying time outdoors. With so many updates already completed, this move-in-ready home is ready for its next owner to make it their own. Don't miss your opportunity to see all this New Carlisle home has to offer!

504 Kennison Ave, New Carlisle

$299,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1049201 MLS

Welcome to 606 W Lake Avenue in New Carlisle! This spacious brick ranch offers nearly 2,000 square feet of above-grade living space, plus an additional nearly 1,700 square feet in the unfinished basement! Featuring 3 bedrooms, additional flexible space ideal for a home office, hobby room, or other uses, 1 full bath, and 2 half baths, this home offers an abundance of space and versatility. Step inside to discover beautiful hardwood floors, fresh neutral paint, updated LED lighting, and new switches and outlets. The beautifully updated kitchen features gorgeous granite countertops, new hardware, stainless steel appliances, and a fresh, modern look that combines style and functionality. The expansive unfinished basement provides exceptional storage space and plenty of possibilities for future use. Situated on a generous 0.66-acre lot, this property also features a fenced backyard and a spacious 3-car garage, offering ample room for parking, outdoor activities, and more. Conveniently located just minutes from downtown New Carlisle, you'll enjoy easy access to local shopping, restaurants, and charming coffee shops like Penny Lane Art Gallery & Cafe. Nearby Smith Park offers additional opportunities for outdoor recreation. With its generous square footage, desirable ranch-style layout, modern updates, convenient location, and spacious indoor and outdoor areas, this home offers an incredible combination of comfort, functionality, and versatility. Schedule your private showing today and see everything this New Carlisle property has to offer!

606 W Lake Ave, New Carlisle

$225,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1049144 MLS

Nearly 40 years of love and care, and it shows! Welcome to 1046 Campbell Avenue in New Carlisle, where pride of ownership shines through every corner! Meticulously maintained by the same homeowners for almost four decades, this home is ready for its next chapter. Inside, you'll find an oversized living room with plenty of space to relax or gather, a dedicated dining area perfect for meals and celebrations, and a spacious kitchen with room to make yourself at home. But just wait until you see what's outside! Along with the attached one-car garage, this property features an impressive three-bay detached garage that's a dream for car enthusiasts, hobbyists, or anyone looking for extra space. Need more? The 12x14 barn, complete with a loft and electric, adds even more possibilities! With a new roof in 2020, a new water heater in 2026, and decades of thoughtful care, this is a home that has truly been loved. Nearly 40 years of memories have been made here. Now it's your turn to make some of your own!

1046 Campbell Ave, New Carlisle

$254,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1049133 MLS

Fully Renovated 1961 Ranch in Park Layne -- $254,900 Welcome to 629 Brumbaugh Dr, a completely renovated ranch that blends established mid-century bones with a top-to-bottom modern remodel. Step inside to find brand-new flooring, fresh paint, and new trim throughout, plus recessed lighting in every bedroom for a warm, custom feel. The kitchen has been fully remodeled with all-new cabinetry, lighting, and flooring. Kitchen appliances -- refrigerator, stove, and dishwasher -- are included and convey with the home. The primary suite is a standout, with a fully remodeled bathroom featuring a double vanity and a new tub/shower combo. A built-in heated exhaust fan with its own thermostat lets you set the bathroom's comfort level independently. A flexible fourth room -- a former garage converted into fully finished living space -- features double-layered 5/8'' drywall on the walls and ceiling for exceptional soundproofing. It's ideal as a home office, nursery, music room, or guest bedroom. Major systems are all recent: a brand-new furnace and central air unit installed this year, plus a hot water heater installed about a year before that. The home is also pre-wired for PoE security cameras, ready for a modern surveillance setup. The newer roof (approximately 5-7 years old and in great shape) covers the home, detached garage, and shed -- all redone at the same time. Outside, a driveway leads back to a detached 2.5-car garage, with a back patio for relaxing or entertaining. A bonus outbuilding -- a shed on a concrete slab with its own shingled roof -- offers excellent storage or workshop potential. Situated in the Park Layne area, just minutes from the brand-new Buc-ee's and within walking distance of the locally famous Mel-O-Dee Restaurant, a neighborhood staple since 1965. With all-new mechanicals, a full cosmetic renovation, and move-in-ready condition, 629 Brumbaugh offers the rare combination of modern updates and classic ranch comfort.

629 Brumbaugh Dr, New Carlisle

$299,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1048981 MLS

Welcome to your private retreat! Nestled on 1.9 tranquil, wooded acres with Indian Creek running through the property, this beautifully updated home offers the perfect blend of privacy, comfort, and modern convenience. The interior feels like new, featuring a completely renovated eat-in kitchen with new countertops, cabinetry, and flooring, along with a new bathroom, updated flooring, and fresh paint throughout. Major improvements provide added peace of mind, including a new furnace, well pump, water softener, insulation, and windows; a newer septic system (2020); and new roofs on the home (2022) and garage (2026). The spacious, deep 2.5-car garage provides ample room for vehicles, storage, hobbies, or a workshop. Enjoy the mature woods, peaceful natural setting, and the convenience of nearby New Carlisle amenities. This is a rare opportunity to own an updated home on a beautiful, private creek side lot. Schedule your showing today and experience the setting for yourself! Shed does not convey.

7788 E Widener Rd, New Carlisle

$299,990

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048709 MLS

WELCOME TO ARBOR HOMES! This thoughtfully designed home offers the ease of single-story living with modern finishes and practical features throughout. Featuring 9-foot first-floor ceilings, the open layout feels bright and spacious from the moment you step inside. The kitchen serves as the heart of the home, showcasing a large island, 42-inch upper cabinetry, a deep stainless steel sink, stainless steel appliances, and durable laminate countertops. The seamless flow into the living area makes it perfect for both everyday living and entertaining, while the rear sliding door brings in natural light and provides easy access to outdoor space. The private primary suite is designed for comfort and convenience with a spacious 60-inch shower and a double-bowl vanity. Laminate countertops continue throughout both the primary and hall bathrooms for a cohesive, low-maintenance finish. Additional highlights include a 2-car front-load garage, LED lighting throughout, a concrete stoop entry, and a sodded front yard that enhances curb appeal. A dusk-to-dawn coach light at the garage adds both style and functionality, completing this beautiful home designed for today's lifestyle.

1308 Plunkett Way, New Carlisle

$240,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048655 MLS

Completely renovated and ready to shine! This beautiful 3-bedroom home in the Tecumseh School District has been updated from top to bottom, so you can move right in and enjoy it without the renovation headaches. The bright front living room features a large window that fills the space with natural light, while the gorgeous new kitchen is sure to be a favorite with brand-new cabinets, granite countertops, new appliances, and a charming breakfast nook. Need more space? The bonus room offers plenty of flexibility and could easily be used as a formal dining room, second living area, office, or whatever fits your lifestyle--and with a brand-new glass sliding door, it opens directly to the large backyard. You'll also find 3 bedrooms, a full bath, and a convenient half bath. The updates go well beyond the cosmetics, with new windows, flooring, paint, lighting, roof, and updates to the plumbing, HVAC, and electrical. Outside, the corner lot gives you plenty of room to spread out, with a large backyard, concrete driveway, and a 2-car garage. Beautifully updated, bright, functional, and ready for its next chapter--this one is definitely worth a look!

1013 W Lake Ave, New Carlisle

$250,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1048581 MLS

ONSITE PUBLIC AUCTION - Wednesday, October 21 at 10am - Real estate sells at 12noon. Outstanding country property featuring 5.05 acres, 3 bedroom home, 30' x 40' Morton metal building with concrete floor & electric, 28' x 50' cement block workshop with 2 garage doors & gas heater, 20' x 38' three car detached garage, creek running through property with bridge, and 2+ acre open field for possible livestock. Home features family room w/ brick fireplace, living room w/ stone fireplace & open to dining area, hardwood floors, full hall bath w/ updated walk-in shower, full unfinished basement w/ laundry room, 2 car attached garage finished with pellet stove, generator back up system, natural gas furnace, central air, and new roof on house, workshop, & 3 car detached garage in 2024. Property has been in the Sheets family for 70 years and has always had the best of care! Appraised at $250,000. Terms - 10% of the purchase price required at close of auction, balance upon delivery of deed within 40 days. Taxes prorated to day of closing. Possession at closing. Real estate has been appraised at $250,000 and sells to the highest bidder subject to confirmation of Trustee.

6540 Lower Valley Pike, New Carlisle

$223,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048473 MLS

Nestled along the outskirts of New Carlisle, this early-1900s Cape Cod is full of character and lovingly maintained by the same owners for over 40 years. Updates include a newer HVAC system, new water heater, vinyl replacement windows, and dimensional roofing, while original charm remains with natural woodwork, spacious rooms, and hardwood floors (covered by existing carpeting). Enjoy a large living room with banister staircase, a main-level bonus room for office/play space, a roomy formal dining area, and an updated kitchen with Corian countertops, center island, and stainless appliances (including gas range and built-in dishwasher). The enclosed rear patio now serves as the main-level laundry, with quick access to the rear sundeck and backyard, plus a full main-level bath. Upstairs offers two privately located bedrooms with excellent closet space. The larger bedroom includes a connecting bath with jetted tub and an adjacent 10x10 bonus area (nursery, sitting area, or secondary office). The finish ed lower level adds a family room, concealed storage, and a flex room that can function as a 3rd bedroom. Outside, you'll find a newer concrete driveway, a 2-car detached garage, and a 16x20 concrete block outbuilding with full electric and lofted storage--perfect for a workshop, she shed, man cave, or garden storage. With strong curb appeal from retaining walls and a covered front porch, this home is clean, well maintained, and priced right--

612 W Madison St, New Carlisle

$224,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048409 MLS

This move-in ready property offers plenty of space and comfort, with features designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious family room is the perfect setting for family gatherings, movie nights, holidays, and creating lasting memories, while the additional living room provides even more flexibility for entertaining, relaxing, or creating a space tailored to your lifestyle. The home offers three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, providing plenty of convenience and functionality for both family and guests. Enjoy the welcoming large front porch, perfect for morning coffee, reading a good book, or visiting with neighbors. Out back, the large back porch overlooks a fully fenced-in yard, creating an ideal space for outdoor entertaining, relaxing, and enjoying time with family and friends. Plus, with a park nearby, you'll have an added opportunity to enjoy outdoor recreation and quality time with the family. Inside, the home has been thoughtfully refreshed with new paint (2026) and new flooring (2026), giving the entire space a clean, fresh, and inviting feel. A new roof installed (2023) provides additional peace of mind. With generous living space, functional amenities, and inviting indoor and outdoor areas, this New Carlisle home is ready to welcome its next family!

413 N Church St, New Carlisle

$299,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048233 MLS

Why wait on new construction when you can have a practically new home without the new build price tag? Built in 2021, this beautifully maintained 3 bedroom, 2 full bath ranch offers modern construction, a desirable single level floor plan and major components, including the roof and mechanical systems that are only approximately 5 years old! Step inside to an inviting open concept layout featuring a spacious great room with gas fireplace and custom mantel, seamlessly connected to the kitchen and dining area. The kitchen offers granite countertops, abundant cabinetry and an oversized eat in island with sink and dishwasher, perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The split bedroom design provides added privacy, with the primary suite tucked away on one side of the home and featuring a generous walk in closet and private ensuite bath with double sinks and step in shower. Two additional bedrooms and a second full bath are located on the opposite side of the home. Outside, enjoy the rear deck overlooking a privacy fenced backyard, mature trees and a storage shed, features buyers often have to add at their own expense when purchasing new construction. An attached 2 car garage completes the package. With a 2021 build, newer roof, newer mechanicals, established landscaping, fencing and outdoor improvements already in place, this home offers the feel and peace of mind of new construction at a fraction of the hassle and potentially the cost. Move in and enjoy from day one!

511 Colony Trl, New Carlisle

$239,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048043 MLS

Welcome to 219 N. Smith Street in New Carlisle's Terra Villa subdivision! This 3-bedroom, 2-bath brick ranch offers 1,664 sq. ft. of comfortable one-level living. Inside, you'll find a spacious living room and a dining room that opens to the kitchen, creating an easy flow for everyday living. Outside, relax on the covered back patio overlooking the backyard, plus a storage shed provides extra space for lawn and garden equipment. A shared well is available for outdoor watering. The 2-car garage adds plenty of room for parking and storage. Conveniently located close to downtown New Carlisle and Smith Park. Come take a look!

219 N Smith St, New Carlisle

$219,900

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1047989 MLS

Built in 1825, this distinctive cabin offers historic character, generous space, and exciting potential on approximately 1.5 acres. The home features four bedrooms with the possibility of a fifth, plus two separate stairways leading upstairs. Recent improvements include a new roof, new HVAC system, new pressure tank, new doors, fresh interior paint, basement waterproofing, and replacement of most windows. A large detached two-car garage provides ample parking, storage, or workshop space. Located in the Northwestern School District, this unique property is ready for its next owner to complete the updates and make it their own.

8021 Troy Rd, New Carlisle

Dayton-Brandt Rd Unit Lot 1, New Carlisle

$295,000

1044681 MLS

Lot 1 - 21.456 Acres A Grand Estate Opportunity with Dual Frontage & Endless Possibility An exceptional opportunity to create a private luxury estate on 21.456 acres in the exclusive Shaw Meadows community. This expansive homesite offers direct frontage along both Agenbroad Rd and Dayton-Brandt Rd, providing flexibility in home placement, access, and design. Exclusively available with D.A. Bowman Construction, a premier custom builder known for exceptional craftsmanship and a seamless, client-focused building experience--ideal for buyers ready to build within the next 12 months. Set in a serene country setting on the outskirts of Northeast Dayton and southeast Tipp City, Shaw Meadows offers the space, privacy, and natural surroundings rarely found in today's market. Enjoy convenient access to I-70 (just 4 miles away), downtown Dayton (16 miles), and Dayton International Airport (13 miles). Outdoor recreation is unmatched, with more than 15 parks and nature preserves within 17 miles, including Charleston Falls Preserve just minutes away--featuring scenic trails, prairie landscapes, and a stunning waterfall. Nearby dining, walking trails, and everyday conveniences complete the lifestyle. Located within the Bethel School District, this is a rare opportunity to secure a large acreage homesite in a thoughtfully planned community. Secure your place in Shaw Meadows--contact us today to walk the land and begin designing your custom home.

Dayton-Brandt Rd Unit Lot 1, New Carlisle

$225,000

1041631 MLS

This property is located in the heart of New Carlisle. This 5.63 acre lot is zoned residential and offers endless opportunities. With excellent access to major roadways.

N Dayton-Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle

$214,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1046319 MLS

Discover the tranquility of New Carlisle living in this charming single-family residence, offering a seamless blend of comfort and convenience. This delightful home presents a unique opportunity to embrace a serene lifestyle within a welcoming community. Its well-maintained exterior and inviting atmosphere create an immediate sense of belonging. The property provides a perfect backdrop for creating lasting memories, making it an ideal setting for anyone seeking a peaceful retreat. Explore the possibilities within this lovely home, where every detail contributes to a comfortable and engaging living experience. Lot of updates have been made to this property including all new flooring. Situated on a generous 0.185-acre lot, the outdoor area offers a wonderful extension of the living space. The expansive grounds provide plenty of room for gardening, outdoor entertaining, or simply unwinding in the fresh air. The neighborhood of New Carlisle offers a friendly environment with convenient access to local amenities and community attractions. Enjoy the peace of mind that comes with residing in a well-established area, perfect for those who value both privacy and community engagement. This home truly represents a fantastic opportunity to own a piece of New Carlisle's charm.

1649 Dale Ridge Rd, New Carlisle

Browse All New Carlisle OH Between $200K - $300K Properties for Sale

Between $200K - $300K New Carlisle Real Estate

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?